Much like the question: Who first thought of eating an oyster…Cheetos with ice cream?

I went to grab some coffee beans from my favorite roaster Porto Rico Coffee in the West Village after work tonight. Since it was on the way, I decided to forgo dinner for a Big Gay Ice Cream cone. (I know, I know)
They started as an ice cream truck on the northwest corner of Union Square in 2009, and quickly got a big following. Using plain soft serve ice cream, they got the attention of people like Andrew Zimmern and Anthony Bourdain by combining flavors like pretzels, sea salt and chocolate, balsamic reduction, dulce de leche or even wasabi powder with the ice cream, using amazing names like Salty Pimp, Bea Arthur and American Globs (the nod to Neil Gaiman). We’re talking 20-30+ minute lines at an ice cream truck…and well worth it.
A few years ago they opened some brick and mortar stores (yay!) They added a line of ice cream pints you can buy in different stores around a few states, and a line of paletas. The stores also offer limited featured flavors, and I missed Cheat-Ohs the last time around. Yep. Cheetos ice cream covered in Cheetos dust.
I took a bite and immediately thought, “Dear Lord. What have I done?”
It’s a shame someone didn’t take my picture when I was trying to figure out what was going on there. I let my taste buds get used to the idea for a moment, took another bite and then another…and God help me if it didn’t taste better and better. That cone is far more delicious than it has any right to be. It’s downright tasty, and if you love cheese, this is pretty cheesy.
While Cheat-Ohs will never be my favorite (Hello Salty Pimp and American Globs), I’ll definitely get at least one cone every time they offer it up. Go check them out, and see if your local store will start carrying the pints. You may never go back to Cherry Garcia again. (blasphemy!)
Much Love,
Gloria